General Election
U.S. House · New York - 12
Open seat in NY-12 draws diverse field of candidates
This is an open seat race with no incumbent on the ballot, featuring a field of six candidates including Micah C. Lasher, who has raised over $2.6 million, far outpacing others. Issues range from health care and immigration to housing and government accountability, reflecting a competitive primary.
Issues
14 issues · 4 candidates · every claim sourced
Ensuring Health Care for All
Lasher and Ortiz support Medicare for All, while Wintrich focuses on price transparency and ending abusive drug pricing.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher believes health care is a right and supports Medicare for All or a similar universal plan. He also wants to lower prescription drug prices and fight against RFK Jr.'s anti-vaccine policies.
Campaign Platform ↗Karen Ortiz
Ortiz supports Medicare for All to ensure universal access to affordable, quality healthcare including gender-affirming care, abortion, fertility treatments, vaccinations, and full-service dental care. She believes healthcare should not be tied to employment and that politicians should not interfere in personal healthcare decisions.
Campaign website ↗Lucian Wintrich
Lucian Wintrich supports forcing total price transparency, capping abusive drug pricing, and ending prior-authorization delays to reduce healthcare costs. He also opposes pharmacy benefit manager kickbacks and insurer denial of care.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Negron, Huhn
Protecting Immigrants and Defending Civil Rights
Lasher condemns Trump-era immigration enforcement; Ortiz calls for abolishing ICE; Wintrich demands federal reimbursement for NYC's migrant costs and prioritizes high-wage H-1B visas.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher condemns the Trump administration's treatment of immigrants, including ICE raids, detention, and deportations. He pledges to protect immigrant communities, defend civil rights and voting rights, and oppose the administration's authoritarian policies.
Campaign Platform ↗Karen Ortiz
Ortiz argues that ICE has repeatedly violated the Constitution and due process, with over 30 deaths in custody in 2025. She believes ICE cannot be rehabilitated and must be dismantled and abolished, and that Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem should be held accountable.
Campaign website ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich demands full federal reimbursement for New York City’s emergency spending on the migrant crisis and transparent federal accounting.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Negron, Huhn
Improving Public Safety and Quality of Life
Lasher emphasizes school, subway, and gun safety; Wintrich supports judicial transparency, fentanyl trafficking penalties, and targeted surveillance with warrants.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher focuses on safety in schools, subways, and places of worship, supporting local police efforts against reckless e-bikers, investing in mental health care, and strengthening gun safety laws. He also addresses quality-of-life issues like scaffolding, illegal weed shops, and helicopter noise.
Campaign Platform ↗Caroline Shinkle
Prioritizes the safety and security of New Yorkers and their livelihoods, and champions law enforcement officers and first responders.
Caroline's Priorities ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports a Judicial Transparency framework with public data and oversight to expose patterns of releasing violent offenders.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Tackling Affordability
Lasher highlights high housing, rent, and child care costs; Wintrich proposes cutting federal tariffs and creating an essential-purchases rebate.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher identifies the affordability crisis as a key issue, focusing on high housing costs, rising rents, insurance premiums, utility bills, and child care costs. He commits to creating more housing and expanding access to affordable child care.
Campaign Platform ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports cutting federal tariffs and excise taxes on essential household goods and creating an annual rebate or deduction tied to essential purchases.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Holding Big Tech Corporations Accountable and Putting Safeguards on AI
Lasher calls for AI regulation to protect safety and civil rights; Wintrich supports opt-in licensing for AI use and EU-style privacy standards.
The data behind the debate
Outside Spending in NY-12 Primary: Pro-AI vs. Safety Groups
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher argues that Congress must regulate AI to protect safety, workforce, civil rights, and the environment. He criticizes the use of AI by the Trump administration for surveillance and military actions, and warns against unchecked data centers, automation, and disinformation.
Campaign Platform ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports opt-in licensing, clear labeling, and audit trails for AI use of creative and professional work, with penalties for unauthorized data harvesting. He also backs worker retention incentives to discourage replacement layoffs.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Strengthening our Public Schools and Colleges
Lasher opposes Trump's efforts to dismantle the Department of Education and cut school funding; the other candidate advocates for revamping education quality and affordability.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher, a public school graduate and parent, opposes Trump's efforts to dismantle the Department of Education, cut school funding, ban books, and garnish wages for student loan debt. He supports fighting back to protect public education.
Campaign Platform ↗Caroline Shinkle
Advocates for revamping and revitalizing the quality and affordability of the education system, and fostering excellence by treating every student like an honors student using best practices and innovative approaches.
Caroline's Priorities ↗No public position yet from Ortiz, Negron, Huhn, Wintrich
Energy Production
One candidate supports lowering costs through increased energy production; Wintrich backs next-generation nuclear projects for NYC.
Caroline Shinkle
Supports lowering the cost of living through increasing energy production and reducing regulatory inefficiencies.
Caroline's Priorities ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports next-generation nuclear projects and fast-tracked federal approvals to provide affordable, constant electricity for New York City.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Lasher, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Stopping Corruption
Lasher criticizes corporate money in politics; Wintrich supports a congressional stock trading ban, insider trading investigations, and term limits.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher calls the Trump administration the most corrupt in U.S. history and criticizes the influence of big corporate money in politics, especially after Citizens United. He supports reducing the influence of money in politics and reforming the system.
Campaign Platform ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports a full ban on stock trading for members of Congress, investigations into family insider trading, and a constitutional amendment for congressional term limits.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Restoring a Principled, Lawful, and Effective Foreign Policy
Lasher criticizes Trump's foreign policy and calls for Congress to reassert its power; the other candidate supports peace through prosperity and strength.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher criticizes Trump's foreign policy, including threats to NATO, tariffs, and military actions. He believes Congress should reassert its constitutional power over foreign policy and restore U.S. leadership based on diplomacy, human rights, and the rule of law.
Campaign Platform ↗Caroline Shinkle
Supports protecting the homeland through peace through prosperity and peace through strength, and standing with allies by strategically promoting the principles upon which the country was founded.
Caroline's Priorities ↗No public position yet from Ortiz, Negron, Huhn, Wintrich
Housing Affordability
One candidate supports reducing housing costs; Wintrich ties federal funds to cracking down on vacant units and offers a first-time buyer credit.
The data behind the debate
Homeownership Rate in NY-12 vs. National Average
Caroline Shinkle
Supports reducing housing costs and increasing opportunity for home ownership.
Caroline's Priorities ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich proposes tying federal housing funds to cracking down on ghost buildings and vacant units, and creating a $25,000 refundable credit for first-time buyers of co-ops and condos.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Lasher, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Strengthening Rights and Protections for the LGBTQ+ Community
Lasher champions LGBTQ+ equality; Ortiz pledges to codify protections for LGBTQIA+ people and other vulnerable groups.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher condemns the Trump administration's assault on LGBTQ+ Americans and pledges to champion LGBTQ+ equality and civil rights. He has the support of community leaders like Brad Hoylman-Sigal and Deborah Glick.
Campaign Platform ↗Karen Ortiz
Ortiz pledges to introduce legislation that fully protects the rights of LGBTQIA+ people, homeless people, incarcerated people, and non-citizens. She wants to codify case law such as Bostock v. Clayton County and disparate treatment analysis to shore up civil rights protections.
Campaign website ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Negron, Huhn, Wintrich
Championing Reproductive Health and Freedom
Lasher strongly supports abortion rights; Wintrich backs federal protections for IVF and fertility care and streamlined adoptions.
Micah C. Lasher
Lasher is a strong supporter of abortion rights, having earned the endorsement of Planned Parenthood of Greater New York Votes. He pledges to aggressively defend reproductive freedom against state bans and federal attacks.
Campaign Platform ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports ironclad federal protections for IVF and fertility care, including medical privacy and coverage safeguards. He also supports streamlining adoptions for qualified families and strengthening oversight to prevent abuse in foster care.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Tax and Spending
One candidate supports keeping more earnings and balanced budgets; Wintrich proposes repealing the SALT cap, raising income thresholds, and eliminating federal income tax for those under $200,000.
Caroline Shinkle
Supports allowing people to keep more of what they earn and offering balanced budget amendments to keep Washington spending in check and drive down the cost of capital.
Caroline's Priorities ↗Lucian Wintrich
Wintrich supports repealing the cap on the State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction to end what he calls double taxation of New Yorkers.
Campaign Platform – 24 Points ↗No public position yet from Lasher, Ortiz, Negron, Huhn
Fighting Back Against Trumpism
Lasher argues Democrats must resist Trump's authoritarian actions; Ortiz vows to introduce Articles of Impeachment on Day One.
Micah C. Lasher
Micah Lasher argues that Democrats in Congress must do more to resist Donald Trump's authoritarian actions, including ignoring the Constitution, manufacturing emergencies, and undermining due process. He has written blueprints for state-level resistance and plans to use aggressive oversight and procedural roadblocks to fight back.
Campaign Platform ↗Karen Ortiz
Karen Ortiz believes it is Congress's duty to impeach, convict, and remove Donald Trump for unconstitutional actions and violations of his oath. She vows to introduce Articles of Impeachment on Day One if elected.
Campaign website ↗No public position yet from Shinkle, Negron, Huhn, Wintrich